A Single "Worldwide" Will

A Single "Worldwide" Will | Bestar

International Wills: Complexities and Solutions

A single "worldwide" will that comprehensively covers all assets in every country is generally not advisable and can lead to significant complications, delays, and increased costs in estate administration. While the concept of one will governing everything might seem simpler, the reality of differing legal systems, inheritance laws, and tax regulations across jurisdictions makes it impractical.

Here's a breakdown of why a single worldwide will is problematic and what approaches are generally recommended:

Why a Single Worldwide Will Often Doesn't Work:

• Differing Legal Requirements: Each country has its own specific legal requirements for the validity of a will, such as witnessing rules, signing procedures, and even the types of assets that can be disposed of by a will. A will valid in one country might be invalid in another.

• Forced Heirship Rules: Many civil law jurisdictions have "forced heirship" rules that dictate a certain portion of an estate must pass to specific family members (e.g., children, spouse), regardless of the testator's wishes. A will drafted under the laws of a country without such rules might be challenged or overridden in a country that has them.

• Probate Processes: The legal process of proving a will and administering an estate (probate) varies significantly from country to country. A single will would likely need to go through probate in each jurisdiction where assets are located, which can be time-consuming, expensive, and complex.

• Language Barriers: A will written in one language might need to be officially translated into the language of another jurisdiction, adding costs and potential for disputes over interpretation.

• Tax Implications: Each country has its own tax laws regarding inheritance and estate taxes. A single will might not be able to effectively address these different tax regimes, potentially leading to higher overall tax burdens.

• Recognition Issues: A will made in one country may not be automatically recognized as valid in another. Some countries may require additional legal steps, such as "resealing" a Grant of Probate obtained in another jurisdiction. Certain countries might not recognize foreign wills at all, applying their own inheritance laws instead.

Recommended Approaches for International Assets:

Given the complexities, estate planning for individuals with assets in multiple countries typically involves one or a combination of the following strategies:

• Multiple Wills (Situs Wills): This is often the most recommended approach. Creating separate wills, each specifically addressing the assets located in a particular jurisdiction, can streamline the probate process in each country. Each will can be tailored to comply with local laws and potentially address local tax implications more effectively. To avoid conflicts, each will should clearly state that it only applies to the assets within that specific jurisdiction and does not revoke any prior wills for assets in other countries.

• International Will (under the UNIDROIT Convention): The Convention Providing a Uniform Law on the Form of an International Will, established in 1973, aims to simplify the recognition of wills across participating countries. Wills executed in accordance with the requirements of this convention are more likely to be recognized as formally valid in other member states. Key requirements include the will being in writing, signed by the testator in the presence of two witnesses and an authorized person, and a certificate from the authorized person confirming compliance with the Convention's requirements. However, it's important to note that not all countries are signatories to this convention, and the convention primarily addresses the form of the will, not its content (which can still be subject to local inheritance laws).

• Trusts: In some cases, establishing trusts can be a useful tool for managing and transferring international assets. Trusts can potentially avoid probate in certain jurisdictions and offer flexibility in estate planning. However, the recognition and tax treatment of trusts vary significantly between countries, so expert legal advice is crucial.

Key Considerations for International Estate Planning:

• Domicile and Residence: Determining the testator's domicile (permanent legal home) and tax residence is crucial as it can significantly impact which country's laws govern the estate and how it will be taxed.

• Situs of Assets: The physical location (situs) of assets, especially immovable property like real estate, often determines which country's laws will apply to its inheritance.

• Professional Advice: It is essential to consult with legal professionals who specialize in international estate planning in each relevant jurisdiction. They can advise on the best approach based on the individual's circumstances, the location and nature of their assets, and their wishes. Tax advisors with international expertise are also crucial for navigating cross-border tax implications.

In conclusion, while a single "worldwide" will might seem like a convenient solution, the complexities of international law make it generally impractical and potentially problematic. Creating multiple wills tailored to specific jurisdictions or utilizing an international will in conjunction with local legal advice are usually more effective strategies for managing and distributing assets located in different countries.

How Bestar can Help

Bestar plays crucial roles in navigating the complexities of international estate planning. Here's a breakdown of how we can help:

• Drafting Jurisdiction-Specific Wills (Situs Wills): We can prepare legally sound wills tailored to the specific requirements of each country where you hold assets. This ensures the will is valid and enforceable in that jurisdiction.

• Ensuring Compliance with Local Laws: We understand the intricacies of local inheritance laws, including:

  • Formal Validity: Witnessing rules, signing procedures, and other legal formalities.

  • Substantive Validity: Forced heirship rules, restrictions on who can inherit, and the types of assets that can be bequeathed.

  • Probate Procedures: We can guide you through the local probate process, which varies significantly between countries.

• Advising on International Wills: We can explain the requirements and limitations of the UNIDROIT Convention on International Wills and help you determine if this is a suitable option for your situation.

• Establishing and Managing Trusts: We can help set up international trusts, advise on their legal implications in different jurisdictions, and ensure they comply with relevant trust laws.

• Navigating Cross-Border Legal Issues: We can assist with issues such as:

  • Recognition of Foreign Wills: Understanding the processes for recognizing a will made in one country in another.

  • Conflict of Laws: Determining which country's laws will apply to specific assets or aspects of your estate.

• Providing Clarity on Domicile and Residence: We can help determine your legal domicile and tax residence, which are crucial factors in international estate planning.

• Coordinating with Foreign Legal Counsel: We can work with lawyers in other countries to ensure a cohesive and effective international estate plan.

• Identifying and Analyzing International Tax Implications: We can assess the potential tax liabilities in each country where you hold assets, including:

  • Inheritance Tax/Estate Duty: Understanding the rates, thresholds, and exemptions in each relevant jurisdiction.

  • Gift Tax: Advising on the tax implications of lifetime gifts made across borders.

  • Capital Gains Tax: Considering the tax implications of transferring assets upon death.

• Developing Tax-Efficient Estate Planning Strategies: We can help structure your estate plan to minimize overall tax burdens, taking into account the tax laws of all relevant countries. This might involve strategies such as:

  • Utilizing tax treaties: Understanding and leveraging double taxation agreements between countries.

  • Strategic asset allocation: Considering the tax implications of holding different types of assets in different locations.

  • Lifetime gifting strategies: Where appropriate, advising on tax-efficient ways to transfer assets during your lifetime.

• Ensuring Compliance with Tax Reporting Requirements: We can help you understand and comply with the tax reporting obligations in each relevant country, both during your lifetime and after your death.

• Advising on the Tax Implications of Trusts: We can explain the tax treatment of international trusts in different jurisdictions.

• Coordinating with Foreign Tax Advisors: We can work with tax professionals in other countries to ensure a comprehensive and coordinated tax strategy.

Bestar works to develop a holistic plan that addresses both the legal and tax aspects of your cross-border assets. We can ensure that your estate plan is not only legally sound but also tax-efficient, minimizing potential complications and costs for your beneficiaries.

Bestar ensures your wishes are legally valid and enforceable across borders, while helping minimize the financial impact of transferring those assets.

Request for Proposal